Downside School physics teacher banned for life after threatening pupils and punching wall
David Hicks pushed a pupil against a wall and told another he would go to jail for three years if he beat him.

What happened at Downside School
A physics teacher at an independent school in Somerset has been banned from the classroom indefinitely after threatening pupils, pushing one against a wall, and punching the masonry close to their heads during lessons.
David Hicks, 66, was teaching at Downside School, a £44,000-a-year private Catholic school in Stratton-on-the-Fosse, when the incidents occurred in February 2025.
A Teaching Regulation Agency (TRA) conduct panel heard that Hicks cornered one student, known as Pupil A, pushing him against a wall and grabbing his face while telling him "I am the alpha male" and "this is dumb insolence". He went on to say: "I would really like to punch your face in" and "once I start hitting you I won't stop."
Hicks told the boy that if he ever snapped, the pupil "should hope there is an adult near who can drag me off him", before punching the wall near the child's head to "get his attention".
Later the same day, Hicks grabbed a second student, Pupil B, by the shoulders and asked: "If I hit you, I would go to jail for two years. If I beat you, I would go to jail for three years. Which one do you think I would prefer?" When the pupil answered the latter option, Hicks replied: "Yes, you're right." He then punched the wall next to Pupil B's head, later claiming words had not been working on him.
What the regulatory panel found
Hicks did not attend the TRA hearing, but admitted making the statements and punching the wall. He initially disputed grabbing Pupil A by his jacket, but the panel concluded he was angry at the time and found all allegations proven on the balance of probabilities.
The panel heard that Hicks subsequently described himself in an interview as someone who did not "tolerate heat very well", explaining that his "rational mind" failed to "compute" during emotionally fraught situations.
Although Hicks expressed some remorse, panel members highlighted his disrespectful attitude towards the children throughout the investigation. During interviews, he referred to Pupil B as "a stupid boy who asked stupid questions" and stated that he had "very little respect or time for [Pupil A] as a human".
Decision-maker David Oatley ruled that Hicks's conduct fell significantly short of professional standards, writing: "In my judgement, the lack of full insight and remorse means that there is some risk of the repetition of this behaviour and this puts at risk the future wellbeing of pupils."
What happens next
The TRA issued an indefinite prohibition order, barring Hicks from teaching in any school, sixth form college, youth accommodation or children's home in England. He cannot apply for the prohibition order to be set aside until 2034 at the earliest.
Downside School confirmed that Hicks left his job at the school in March 2025, a month after a complaint was logged in its internal safeguarding system.
Michael Randall, the interim headteacher at Downside School, said the school cooperated fully with the investigation and supported the panel's decision, adding that the safety and wellbeing of pupils remains the school's highest priority.
Key numbers
| What | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Teacher age | 66 | Teaching Regulation Agency panel proceedings |
| Annual fees at Downside School | £44,000 | Downside School published fee details |
| Earliest review date for prohibition order | 2034 | Teaching Regulation Agency |
| Date of classroom incidents | 5 February 2025 | Downside School safeguarding log |
| Teacher departure date | March 2025 | Statement by interim headteacher Michael Randall |
In this story
| Name | Role in the story |
|---|---|
| David Hicks | Former physics teacher at Downside School who was indefinitely banned from teaching. |
| Downside School | Independent Catholic school in Somerset where the incidents occurred. |
