The India Decade

Stephen Flynn faces cover-up claims over CalMac ferry gas leak emails

The Scottish Transport Secretary told MSPs he knew nothing about the MV Glen Sannox incident, but records show his office was sent briefings minutes beforehand.

By The India Decade

ferry docked at a terminal under grey skies (file image)
ferry docked at a terminal under grey skies (file image) · “Southern Terminal Docks” by Eli Dark (BY-SA 2.0) via Flickr

Scottish Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn is facing allegations of attempting to cover up his knowledge of a major ferry gas leak, after records showed he was emailed about the incident just minutes before telling MSPs he knew nothing about it.

During his first appearance before the Scottish Parliament’s transport committee on 9 September, Mr Flynn claimed he was unaware of a morning news report revealing a methane leak on the MV Glen Sannox. He told MSPs he had missed the news because he was Facetiming his children.

But newly released emails obtained through a freedom of information request show that Mr Flynn’s office was sent two briefing emails at 08:48 and 09:04—shortly before the committee met at 09:15. The emails included suggested comments if MSPs asked about the leak.

The cleared statement

The row has intensified following the leak of further emails from later that afternoon, first published by The Sun. At 17:04 on the day of the committee hearing, an official from Mr Flynn's office sent an email clearing a statement that insisted: "I was not briefed on this incident, however details were shared with the former cabinet secretary for transport on 30 June 2025."

Opposition politicians have reacted furiously. Willie Rennie, the Liberal Democrat convener of the transport committee, accused the minister of trying to execute a cover-up.

"What is alarming is that he seems to have attempted a cover-up, dragging in officials and Transport Scotland," Mr Rennie told BBC Scotland. He added that if the minister had listened to the morning news, he would not have been caught out.

Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay urged Mr Flynn to refer himself to independent advisers on the ministerial code, calling the emails "bombshell new evidence" of a "sleekit, skin-saving cover-up" with officials.

The government response

Transport Scotland has defended the minister, arguing that the emails did not count as a formal briefing.

A spokesperson said that while a draft media statement was sent to Mr Flynn’s office shortly before he arrived at the committee, it was not actually shown to him. "A high-level media statement does not constitute formal briefing, which the cabinet secretary received later," the spokesperson said.

What happened on the MV Glen Sannox

The gas leak itself happened on 3 June 2025 on the MV Glen Sannox, a dual-fuel vessel built at the Ferguson Marine shipyard in Port Glasgow. A faulty valve led to 700kg of methane gas venting from the side of the ship while it was carrying over 80 passengers between Arran and Troon.

Because the ship’s engines had been supplied by Finnish subcontractor Wartsila without certain monitoring equipment, the crew did not realise there was a leak for 12 minutes. They only acted when gas was sucked back into the engine room, setting off alarms.

Transport Scotland confirmed that the previous transport secretary, Fiona Hyslop, had been formally briefed about the leak when it happened in June last year.

Key numbers

WhatFigureSource
Methane gas leaked700kgTransport Scotland
Duration of gas leak before crew intervened12 minutesInvestigation records
Times of briefing emails sent to Flynn08:48 and 09:04FOI emails
Time Flynn's office cleared statement denying briefing17:04Leaked emails

In this story

NameRole in the story
Stephen FlynnScottish Transport Secretary accused of a cover-up over ferry gas leak emails.

Topics

The day’s reporting, once each morning. No advertising.

More on this story